I found two drastically different ways of knowing through the work I’ve been doing in the archives, and the work I’ve done with the oral histories with the band.
When we initially started archiving the letters, I found it somewhat overwhelming. This had to do in part with the sheer amount of letters in the box and also with how far back into the band’s history these letters went. I was having a hard time visualizing how I could connect the personal letters I was going through in these boxes with the band as it is today. I was worried that the personal qualities of the letters would make it irrelevant to the band today because obviously, the people in the letters are no longer a part of the band. However, I came to discover that it was the personal qualities of the letters that made them so interesting to me. Through all the letters I have read, I feel like I have come to know people like Meyers and Bob Hoe, and a bunch of other guest conductors and fans of the band. I know the way they speak and the kind of things they like to talk about, and why they care about the band. I was really struck by what Popova said about reading, and the way she offered an interpretation of it as “a relationship to one’s own mind and not a relationship to the matter of silicon or pulped wood.” While the letters taught me about the people writing them, I was also able to find myself in them. There would be moments of humor that sometimes don’t serve the purpose of the letter, but that’s one of the crucial parts of how humans interact with one another. At least it is crucial to the way in which I interact with the people in my life. And while yes, the letters don’t entirely reflect the band as it is today, I think it is the spirit of the people in the letters that lives on today.
Similarly, the personal quality of the oral histories has also made me feel even more invested and in touch with the band. Up until I conducted my interview, the band was more of an illusive concept than a real life thing for me. Talking with DeVaughn was really wonderful, and I was able to get his unique perspective on why he wanted to join the band, why he sticks with it, what his favorite parts are, and I was also able to learn things about him that have nothing to do with the band. Having the opportunity to experience band members as fully fleshed out people rather than just entities in the band was really helpful for me in viewing the band as the sort of living, breathing being that it truly is.
On the one hand, I am able to know the band through things like the information I can gather from the letters or from Ron’s book, and I can understand the band from a historical aspect. On another hand, I can learn about the relationships between people involved in the band, and the personalities of current members, and it suddenly becomes so much more alive to me.
1 Comment
Your reflections illustrate how widely and deeply one can know a person and a group and how their relationships form from personalities to create the greater whole. Thanks so much.